Joe Schmoe on "[Plugin: WP-Members: Membership Framework] WP-Members conflict with Wordfence Security"

I have the WP-Members plugin installed and it does exactly what I want (when the user goes to a private page, they are presented with a login / register page, and then redirected to the private content after they log in.

But it works only if Wordfence Security (free version) is disabled. Has anyone been successful in getting these two plugins to work together?

https://wordpress.org/plugins/wp-members/

This is not discussing the same plugin, but it is likely the same answer and solution:
http://rocketgeek.com/tips-and-tricks/workaround-for-wp-members-front-end-login-when-using-si-captcha-on-the-wp-login-form/

Thanks Chad, I will look into that possible solution and post my results.
Jeff