sandyflees on "[Plugin: Contact Form 7] Syntax Error with Selectable Recipient with Pipes"

We have a contact page setup using Contact Form 7 with the Selectable Recipient with Pipes. We have it setup exactly as described on this page: http://contactform7.com/selectable-recipient-with-pipes/

One thing is that it continuously shows a syntax error in the To field, so I put an asterisk after [select and now the syntax error is gone, but we still never receive any emails. When using the form it says "Your message was sent successfully. Thanks.". But nothing ever comes through. In the "from" field I have [your-email] but it has the following error: "This email address does not belong to the same domain as the site." I have tried to change this as well but nothing I do makes the emails come through.

Any help would be appreciated! I have included links to screen shots of how we have it setup.

http://www.grafixdesigners.com/screenshot1.png
http://www.grafixdesigners.com/screenshot2.png
http://www.grafixdesigners.com/screenshot3.png

https://wordpress.org/plugins/contact-form-7/